HOME ON
Deal Scout · Opportunity #1
Download PDF ← Back to overview
GOOD · 21.5% margin · 97.4% cash-on-cash MARGIN $10M–$15M project

#1 · 1511/1525 Tallyho Trail, Chapel Hill, NC 27516

24.06 acres · 2 parcels · Fox Meadow adjacent · public sewer · MLS #10047640
List price$2,550,000 for both parcels combined (MLS #10047640)
Acreage24.06 ac (2 parcels: 1511 + 1525 Tallyho Trail)
MLS#10047640 · Orange County · Carrboro jurisdiction
ZoningRR — Carrboro (1-ac min lot; rezoning to higher density cited as possible in listing)
UtilitiesPublic sewer main traverses property (recent extension); public water and electric available
StrategySubdivide 14 lots (1-ac min, conservative); build 14 × 3,000 SF custom homes; entitlement upside on rezone
Out-of-pocket cash$3,436,995 (equity + closings + carry)
Financed$7,666,163 construction loan (~75% of $10,221,550 total project)
Modeled14 lots × 3,000 SF · $370/SF ARV · $111/SF builder grade · 20% intro margin · 24-mo build
Project cost
$11.1M
Gross revenue
$15,540,000
Net profit
+$3,349,042
Margin
21.5% margin · 97.4% cash-on-cash
Max offer (20%)
$2,767,402
Pro Forma
LineAmount
Gross revenue — 14 homes × $1,110,000 ($370/SF × 3,000 SF, new custom construction)$15,540,000
Land acquisition + closing (~2%)($2,601,000)
Construction — builder cost (14 homes · 42,000 SF × $111 builder grade)($4,662,000)
Home On builder margin (20% intro rate; standard 30%)($1,165,500)
Site development / infrastructure (14 lots public utilities + 13-lot roads, incl. 20% margin)($1,093,750)
Soft costs — design/permits/survey (5% of construction, at cost)($233,100)
Contingency (10% of construction, AT COST — typically returned if unused)($466,200)
Construction loan closing + carry (1.5% closing + 10% APR on 24-mo draws)($881,608)
Selling costs (~7%) — paid at sale closing, not out-of-pocket($1,087,800)
NET PROFIT TO INVESTOR~$3,349,042 · 21.5% margin · 97.4% cash-on-cash

ARV support: 1003 Tallyho Trail (adjacent Fox Meadow) sold 3/27/2026 $725,000/2,461 SF = $294.60/SF; 8107 Kit Lane CH sold 11/2024 $708,800/2,287 SF = $309.90/SF; Fox Meadow 5/2025 $578,000/1,820 SF = $317.58/SF. New custom 3,000 SF homes on 1-ac lots modeled at $370/SF (16% premium over recent existing comps — standard for new custom construction); break-even ARV = $362/SF. MAO $2,767,402 at $370/SF (ask $2,550,000 is $217,402 below MAO — solid cushion). UNVERIFIED — confirm against new construction sold comps in Carrboro/CH before offer.

Diligence Gates
GO: Public sewer main confirmed traversing property (per listing); adjacent to established Fox Meadow subdivision; 5 miles to UNC and UNC Hospitals; RR zoning with precedent for rezoning if public sewer available; Orange County MLS active listing. VERIFY: Confirm MLS still active and days on market; pull Orange County GIS/CAMA for parcel boundaries, road frontage, and recorded acreage; check FEMA FIRM for flood zone exposure (Watkins area); verify Carrboro ETJ vs. city limits jurisdiction; get Carrboro Planning assessment on UDO rewrite and rezone feasibility with sewer in place; survey lot yield and road layout for 14-lot conservative plan; confirm sewer connection feasibility and cost per lot; verify no deed restrictions or conservation easements; confirm no HOA covenants from adjacent Fox Meadow; check Neuse River buffer applicability. STOP: If FEMA flood zone covers >20% of gross acreage; if Carrboro flatly rejects any rezoning; if sewer connections require pumping or force main at prohibitive cost; if deed restrictions preclude subdivision.
Verdict

Best development play in this scan. The price is essentially at or below the MAO for a straightforward 14-lot, 1-acre-minimum build-out: at the $370/SF ARV target the investor nets +$3,349,042 (21.5% margin, 97.4% cash-on-cash). Conservative case at $350/SF yields 17.5% margin — near-miss on the 20% hurdle that could be fixed with a modest price negotiation to ~$2.37M. The real prize is entitlement: Carrboro is rewriting its UDO (adoption Winter 2026), and a public sewer main now traverses this property — the strongest argument possible for requesting higher density. If rezoned to R-15 (15,000 SF lots), yield climbs to ~40 lots and the deal becomes exceptional. Home On is a licensed NC GC (L-103184) — this is a natural build-invest fit. Recommend site visit + Carrboro Planning meeting before offer. Ask price $2,550,000; negotiate toward $2.37M ($2.37M is the MAO for 20% margin at conservative $350/SF).

Deal Scout · 2026-09-22 Home On LLC · NC GC L-103184Confidential — Home On LLC