HOME ON
Deal Scout · Opportunity #1
Download PDF ← Back to overview
GOOD · 21.1% MARGIN $1M–$5M project

#1 · Lot 1 Orange Grove Street, Hillsborough, NC 27278

Lot 1 Orange Grove St, Hillsborough NC — 3.63 wooded acres, R1 | MLS 10178047
List price$260,000
Acreage3.63 acres (Orange County, unincorporated)
MLS10178047 (Fathom Realty NC, active 14 DOM)
ZoningR1 — Orange County (verify min. lot size for subdivision)
UtilitiesPublic water at road; septic — 4-BR perc test on file; 2nd perc test needed for Lot 2
StrategySubdivide → 2 custom homes (2,800 SF ea) + sell
Out-of-pocket cash$417,690 (equity + closings + carry + listing prep)
Financed$1,002,518 construction loan (~75% of $1,336,690 project)
Modeled2 × 2,800 SF custom homes, $350/SF ARV (Forrest Creek Estates comp-supported)
Days on market14
Project cost
$1.41M
Gross revenue
$1,960,000
Net profit
+$412,592
Margin
21.1%
Max offer (20%)
$297,763
Pro Forma
LineAmount
Gross revenue — 2 homes × 2,800 SF × $350/SF (Forrest Creek Estates comp-supported)$1,960,000
Land acquisition + closing (~2%) — Lot 1 Orange Grove St, 3.63 ac($265,200)
Construction — builder cost (5,600 SF × $111 builder grade)($621,600)
Home On builder margin (20% intro rate; standard 30%)($155,400)
Site development — 2× well + septic systems (incl. 20% margin)($157,500)
Subdivision infrastructure — 1 new lot carved out (incl. 20% margin)($43,750)
Soft costs — design/permits/survey (5% of builder cost, AT COST)($31,080)
Contingency (10% of builder cost, AT COST — typically returned if unused)($62,160)
Construction loan closing + carry (10% APR on draws, ~14 months)($73,518)
Selling costs (~7%) — paid at sale closing, not out-of-pocket($137,200)
NET PROFIT TO INVESTOR~$412,592 · 21.1% margin · 98.8% cash-on-cash

ARV support — Hillsborough (27278) custom new construction 2026: Forrest Creek Estates 3,200 SF/$1,150,000 ($359/SF), 4,446 SF/$1,635,000 ($368/SF), 2,990 SF/$1,250,000 ($418/SF); mid-range custom 420 W Corbin St $975k/3,087 SF ($316/SF); market avg $262/SF (Sep 2026). Modeled at $350/SF (conservative relative to Forrest Creek). MAO $297,763 — $37,763 cushion below $260k ask; at $340/SF MAO = ~$259k (essentially at ask).

Diligence Gates
GO: Perc test on file for 4-BR; 14 DOM (fresh listing); public water at road; no wetlands flagged; corner markers already set; corner lot with easement access. VERIFY: (1) Orange County R1 minimum lot size for unimproved septic lots — confirm 1.8 ac each clears min; (2) order second soil/perc evaluation on the south half immediately — this is the single critical gate; (3) confirm road access/easement serves both lots; (4) check for Neuse buffer or FEMA zone on stream/drainage features on property; (5) survey for HOA/deed restrictions. STOP: If 2nd perc fails or Orange County min lot size exceeds ~1.8 ac per lot, retreat to single-home scenario (MARGINAL, 9.9% margin at $350/SF).
Verdict

GOOD — buy at or below $260k asking, proceed immediately to order 2nd perc test ($500-$1,500). If the second perc passes: 2 custom homes at 2,800 SF each return $412,592 net profit (21.1% margin, 99% cash-on-cash) with $417,690 out-of-pocket. The MAO at $350/SF is $297,763 — the current ask is $38k below that with nearly $100k in additional buffer before the deal turns marginal. Fallback single-home scenario (if 2nd perc fails): $96,785 net / 9.9% margin at $350/SF — still positive but below the 20% threshold. Hillsborough's luxury custom market ($359-$456/SF at Forrest Creek Estates) strongly supports the $350/SF model for a premium wooded-lot product.

Deal Scout · 2026-09-30 Home On LLC · NC GC L-103184Confidential — Home On LLC